Multi-national companies (MNCs) have always been associated with innovation, world-class processes, and superior technology. Many domestic players aspire to learn from their expertise, making them aspirational brands in the Indian business ecosystem. However, despite these advantages, a significant number of MNCs have exited India over the years. Between 2014 and November 2021 alone, 2,783 foreign companies and their subsidiaries ceased operations in India.
Some of the biggest names that have exited India include General Motors, Ford, Harley-Davidson, MAN, Scania, Akzo Nobel, Novartis, Dockers, Carrefour, Metro AG, Spar, Etisalat, Telenor, Old Mutual, GE Capital, ING, Henkel, Holcim, and Citibank. But why are these global giants failing to sustain their operations in one of the world’s fastest-growing economies? Let’s break down the key reasons for their exit:
- Overestimating Market Potential
Many MNCs enter India with high revenue and profit expectations, assuming large population numbers will automatically translate into high demand. However, factors like low per capita income, affordability, and cultural preferences make mass adoption slower than anticipated.
Example: MAN and Scania trucks struggled in India because their premium pricing didn’t fit the cost-sensitive Indian market.
- Failure to Localize Products and Strategies
MNCs often try to impose global product strategies without adapting to Indian consumer preferences. Many successful products abroad fail in India because they don’t cater to local tastes, packaging expectations, or pricing sensitivity.
Example: McDonald’s succeeded because it adapted to Indian preferences with a vegetarian menu, but many FMCG and consumer goods companies failed because they stuck to their global offerings without customization.
- Inability to Adapt to India’s ‘Jugaad’ Culture
India operates with a unique cost-conscious and innovative approach to business, often called ‘Jugaad.’ MNCs that cannot adapt to these flexible, frugal, and high-volume business models struggle to achieve scale and profitability.
Example: General Motors and Ford couldn’t match the cost efficiency of Indian and Japanese carmakers, leading to sustained losses and eventual exits.
- Struggles Against Fierce Domestic Competition
Local companies understand the Indian market better and often use aggressive pricing, extensive distribution networks, and customer loyalty to outcompete MNCs.
Example: Metro AG, a German wholesaler, exited India after failing to compete with domestic giants like Reliance and D-Mart, who had a deeper grasp of Indian retail needs.
- Regulatory and Legal Hurdles
India’s complex regulatory framework, changing tax policies, and long legal battles make it difficult for MNCs to operate smoothly. Some sectors, such as telecom and retail, have particularly challenging foreign investment policies.
Example: Telecom players like Etisalat and Telenor exited India due to unfavorable regulations and legal disputes.
- Mergers, Acquisitions, and Corporate Restructuring
Sometimes, exits happen due to global-level mergers and business realignments. If the parent company’s priorities shift, they might sell or shut down Indian operations.
Example: Holcim exited the Indian cement market because it saw limited future growth in the sector and wanted to focus on sustainability and green building materials.
- Weak Local Leadership and Unrealistic Targets
Some MNCs appoint leadership teams that lack an in-depth understanding of Indian business dynamics. Unrealistic sales targets, poor financial management, or failure to build strong distributor and retailer relationships often lead to failure.
Example: Ricoh India suffered from financial irregularities and leadership mismanagement, leading to the brand’s downfall.
- Joint Venture (JV) Failures
Many MNCs enter India through joint ventures with local partners. Over time, these partnerships either turn sour, or the local partner learns the business tricks and takes control, forcing the MNC out.
Example: Several B2B companies exited India after their local partners either went bankrupt or took over operations.
- Parent Company Issues in Home Markets
When MNCs face financial struggles in their home markets, they often cut back on international operations to save costs, leading to exits from countries like India.
Example: Whirlpool and Akzo Nobel scaled back Indian operations to focus on core markets in the US and Europe.
- High-Cost Structures and Unviable Business Models
High operational costs, import duties, expensive real estate, and inefficient supply chains make it difficult for some MNCs to sustain profitability in India.
Example: Harley-Davidson struggled to compete with local manufacturers due to high production costs, limited market penetration, and a product lineup that didn’t cater to mass consumers.
Conclusion: Can MNCs Still Succeed in India?
While many global companies have exited India, several have thrived by adapting to local needs, innovating pricing strategies, and investing in strong supply chains. Companies like Unilever, Nestlé, Samsung, and Hyundai have understood what Indian consumers want and built long-term success.
For MNCs to succeed in India, they must:
✅ Understand local preferences and affordability levels.
✅ Be flexible in their product offerings and business models.
✅ Have patience and commit to long-term investment instead of expecting instant success.
✅ Treat India as a standalone market rather than clubbing it under broader regional categories like Asia-Pacific or the Middle East. With its size and population, India deserves a dedicated approach.
India remains one of the biggest opportunities for global businesses, but only those who adapt and innovate will survive in this dynamic and competitive market.
Navigating the complexities of the Indian market requires a nuanced approach and deep understanding of local dynamics. At Crescentia Strategists, we specialize in guiding businesses through these challenges, offering tailored strategies for success. Our expertise encompasses market entry, localization, and operational excellence, ensuring your venture thrives in India’s unique landscape.
Ready to unlock India’s potential?
Contact Crescentia Strategists today to discover how our customized solutions can drive your business forward.
